Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Also note that Cinebench R23 is a terrible general purpose CPU benchmark. It uses Intel Embree engine which is hand optimized for x86. It heavily favors CPUs with many slow cores even though most people will benefit from CPUs with fewer, faster cores.

Cinebench is a great benchmark if you use Cinema4D, which I asumme 99.99% of the people buying these laptops won't use. Cinema4D is a niche of a niche.

Geekbench is far more representative of what kind of performance you can expect from a CPU.

https://reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/pitid6/eli5_why_does_...



> Geekbench is far more representative of what kind of performance you can expect from a CPU.

Geekbench is an even worse benchmark than cinebench. It's extremely heavily influenced by the underlying OS rather than the hardware being compared.

Cinebench 1T and mT at least actually benchmark the hardware.


Benchmark the hardware doing 3D rendering. Which is a pretty niche use case for most people that doesn’t correlate well with more common cpu-intensive tasks like gaming or video editing.


Video editing is just as niche as 3d rendering. But really neither are actually that niche, see for example https://www.blender.org/news/blender-by-the-numbers-2020/

And to put those blender numbers in comparison https://prodesigntools.com/number-of-creative-cloud-subscrib...


> It's extremely heavily influenced by the underlying OS rather than the hardware being compared.

How so?


To clarify, Cinebench correlates poorly with gaming, office software, web browsing, and video editing. Those are what the vast majority of people buying laptops will use it for.

For people that code, it also correlates poorly with parallel code compilation.


Anandtech benchmark puts Intel 12900K on top for both RISCV toolchain compilation and Cinebench.


12900K is the fastest x86 DIY CPU available. It'll be tops in nearly all benchmarks and applications.

You can say the same about gaming. It's tops in Cinebench and most games. Therefore Cinebench and gaming must have a high correlation? No.


Thanks for your input, this isn't said enough. So many CPU benchmarks aren't effective at evaluating the general use case and yet are held up as this golden standard


It's because Cinebench was disproportionately favoring the Zen architecture so AMD pushed it in marketing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: